1
$$Editor's Pick
A clean 5.0 rating across 69 Google reviews. It is a small sample, but there is not a wobble in it.
Lehigh Valley Rankings
The 18 Best Insurance Agents
in Lehigh Valley
Our definitive guide to the top insurance agents in Allentown, Bethlehem, and Easton. Updated for 2026.
Our Lehigh Valley insurance directory lists eighteen local agencies across Allentown, Bethlehem, and Easton, every one verified against Google Places. Some operate under a national carrier name such as State Farm or Allstate, and others under their own names. Rankings reflect verified Google ratings and review volume. We list and rank local agencies; we do not provide insurance advice, and coverage questions belong with your agent.
Sponsored
2
$$Featured
263 Google reviews at 4.9 stars. Handy if you would rather sort out coverage across a desk than over the phone.
3
$$
More than 700 Google reviews and still a perfect 5.0, which is a striking combination at that volume.
4
$$
596 reviews averaging a flat 5.0. If you want a local agency office rather than a call center, this one has the record behind it.
5
Photo: Silver Crest Insurance via Google471 Google reviews and a 5.0 average. Worth a call if you are shopping coverage anywhere around Bethlehem.
6
Photo: Koch Protect Insurance Incorporated via Google930 Google reviews at 5.0 stars, the deepest review record of any insurance agency in our directory data.
7
Photo: Solano Insurance Group via GoogleMore than 800 Google reviews averaging 4.9 stars, one of the deepest review records of any agency listed here.
8
$$
4.9 stars from 268 reviews, plus a free lot, which is not a given at an in-town office.
9
Photo: Mearhoff Insurance Agency, Inc. via Google$$
Under 100 reviews so far, but they average 4.9 stars. A sensible local option if you prefer dealing with an agency rather than an app.
10
Photo: D E Cressman Insurance Agency Inc. via Google$$
94 Google reviews averaging 4.9 stars, and Google reports full wheelchair access, from the parking to the seating.
11
Photo: Jim Habick - State Farm Insurance Agent via Google$$
61 Google reviews averaging 4.9. Modest numbers, but consistent ones, and the Northampton St address is simple to find.
12
$$
4.8 stars across 115 reviews. Between the free lot and the accessible seating, it is a low-friction visit.
13
Photo: Marty McGuire via Google$$
4.9 stars across 51 Google reviews. A modest sample, but a consistent one. Google does not list office hours, so call ahead before you visit.
14
Photo: Lehigh Partners via Google$$
A perfect 5.0 from 33 Google reviews. The sample is still small, so read a few before you decide.
15
Photo: Alex R. Ramos: Allstate Insurance via Google$$
4.6 stars from 15 Google reviews. That is a small sample, so read a few reviews before you decide.
16
Photo: William P Dadio Jr: Allstate Insurance via Google$$
4.5 stars from 24 Google reviews, and the office keeps weekday hours until 5:30pm.
17
Photo: Cooke Insurance Agency via Google$$
Ratings are more mixed here, 4.2 from 29 reviews, so it is worth reading a few before you commit to anything.
18
Photo: George Denger: Allstate Insurance via Google$$
159 Google reviews make it the second most-reviewed agency in our Easton listings, behind Koch Protect, and it keeps Saturday morning hours.
Insurance Agents Tips & Guides
Aug 4, 2026
Car Insurance Allentown PA: Local Agencies Compared
Car insurance in Allentown PA: the five local agencies in our directory, with Google ratings, review counts, office hours, and locations.
Mar 31, 2026
Best Insurance Agent in the Lehigh Valley: Independent vs. Captive Agents
Find the best insurance agent in the Lehigh Valley. Compare the top-rated agencies in Allentown, Bethlehem, and Easton by Google rating, review depth, and office hours, and learn what to ask before you choose.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which insurance agency ranks highest in the Lehigh Valley?
YMI Insurance holds the top spots in our insurance rankings, with an Allentown office on Hamilton Blvd (5.0 across 69 Google reviews) and a Bethlehem office on W Broad St (4.9 across 263) in our directory data.
Which Lehigh Valley insurance agency has the most Google reviews?
Koch Protect Insurance Incorporated in Easton, with 930 reviews at 5.0 in our directory data, followed by Solano Insurance Group in Allentown at 867. Elliot Tracey - State Farm in Bethlehem is third, at 715 reviews and also a 5.0.
Are any Lehigh Valley insurance agencies open on Saturday?
Four in our data: Koch Protect Insurance in Easton (9am-6pm), George Denger - Allstate in Easton (9am-noon), Solano Insurance Group in Allentown (10am-2pm), and Frank Armetta - State Farm in Allentown (9am-noon). The rest list weekday hours only or do not publish hours on Google.