Bethlehem, Pennsylvania · Christmas City USA

Best Insurance Agents in Bethlehem

Our curated list of the 4 best insurance agents in Bethlehem, PA. Ranked by Google reviews, local reputation, and our team's research. Updated for 2026.

Bethlehem's insurance category runs four agencies deep in our rankings, and it is the only one of the three cities with no weekend hours at all — every agency here is Monday-through-Friday only. Elliot Tracey - State Farm on Linden St carries the deepest review record, more than 700 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0, an unusual combination at that volume. YMI Insurance's Schoenersville Rd office holds a 4.9 average across 212 reviews, and Silver Crest Insurance matches Elliot Tracey's 5.0 rating across 463. Larry Chapel - State Farm rounds out the four at 4.8 stars. All four report a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking in verified Google data, and Larry Chapel additionally reports wheelchair-accessible seating — the only insurance listing in our directory to do so.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is YMI Insurance in Bethlehem?

YMI Insurance's Bethlehem office is on Schoenersville Rd, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking. It holds a 4.9 rating across 212 Google reviews in our directory data. YMI also has a separate Allentown location on Hamilton Blvd.

What insurance agencies are in Bethlehem, PA?

Four agencies appear in our Bethlehem rankings: YMI Insurance on Schoenersville Rd, Elliot Tracey - State Farm on Linden St, Silver Crest Insurance on Stefko Blvd, and Larry Chapel - State Farm, also on Stefko Blvd. All four hold a rating of 4.8 or better in our directory data.

Which Bethlehem insurance agency has the most Google reviews?

Elliot Tracey - State Farm, with more than 700 reviews in our directory data — the deepest review record of any insurance agency we track in Bethlehem, still averaging a perfect 5.0.

Are Bethlehem insurance agencies open on weekends?

No. All four agencies we track in Bethlehem — YMI Insurance, Elliot Tracey - State Farm, Silver Crest Insurance, and Larry Chapel - State Farm — report weekday-only hours in Google's verified data, with no Saturday or Sunday availability.

Are Bethlehem insurance agencies wheelchair accessible?

Yes. All four agencies in our Bethlehem rankings report a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking in verified Google data. Larry Chapel - State Farm additionally reports wheelchair-accessible seating.