
A clean 5.0 rating across 66 Google reviews. It is a small sample, but there is not a wobble in it.
Allentown, Pennsylvania · The Queen City
Our curated list of the 5 best insurance agents in Allentown, PA. Ranked by Google reviews, local reputation, and our team's research. Updated for 2026.
Allentown's insurance category holds five agencies in our rankings. Two carry the State Farm name, Shawn Leh on Allen St and Frank Armetta on Sumner Ave. The other three, YMI Insurance, Solano Insurance Group, and D E Cressman Insurance Agency, operate under their own names. Every one of the five clears a 4.9 rating, the tightest floor of any city in this category. Solano Insurance Group has by far the most reviews in the city, more than 850 on Google, while YMI Insurance's Hamilton Blvd office holds a perfect 5.0 across 66. Weekend access is thin: Solano is the only agency open Saturday afternoon (10am-2pm), and Frank Armetta adds a shorter 9am-to-noon Saturday window. None of the five report Sunday hours. For an early start, Cressman on Walbert Ave opens at 8:30am on weekdays. Cressman is also the only Allentown agency that reports a wheelchair-accessible entrance, restroom, and seating in verified Google data, and YMI Insurance, Shawn Leh State Farm, and Frank Armetta State Farm report wheelchair-accessible parking.

A clean 5.0 rating across 66 Google reviews. It is a small sample, but there is not a wobble in it.
580 reviews averaging a flat 5.0. If you want a local agency office rather than a call center, this one has the record behind it.
1146 Hamilton St Suite 1, Allentown, PA 18101
More than 800 Google reviews averaging 4.9 stars, one of the deepest review records of any agency listed here.
1501 Sumner Ave, Allentown, PA 18102
4.9 stars from 247 reviews, plus a free lot, which is not a given at an in-town office.
2310 Walbert Ave, Allentown, PA 18104
94 Google reviews averaging 4.9 stars, and Google reports full wheelchair access, from the parking to the seating.
Five agencies appear in our Allentown rankings: YMI Insurance on Hamilton Blvd, Shawn Leh - State Farm on Allen St, Solano Insurance Group on Hamilton St, Frank Armetta - State Farm on Sumner Ave, and D E Cressman Insurance Agency on Walbert Ave. All five hold a rating of 4.9 or better in our directory data.
Solano Insurance Group, with more than 850 reviews in our directory data. That is the most of any agency we track in Allentown, and it still averages 4.9 stars.
YMI Insurance and Shawn Leh - State Farm both hold a perfect 5.0 rating in our directory data, across 66 and 579 reviews respectively. The other three Allentown agencies we track sit at 4.9.
Two: Solano Insurance Group (10am-2pm) and Frank Armetta - State Farm (9am-noon). The other three agencies we track in Allentown, YMI Insurance, Shawn Leh - State Farm, and D E Cressman Insurance Agency, are weekday-only, and none of the five report Sunday hours.
D E Cressman Insurance Agency is at 2310 Walbert Ave in Allentown. In our directory data it holds 4.9 stars across 94 Google reviews and is open Monday to Thursday 8:30am-5pm and Friday 8:30am-4pm.
Four of the five we track report wheelchair-accessible parking in verified Google data: YMI Insurance, Shawn Leh - State Farm, Frank Armetta - State Farm, and D E Cressman Insurance Agency. Cressman also reports an accessible entrance, restroom, and seating. Solano Insurance Group does not report accessibility features.
Looking for car insurance Allentown PA? Compare local agents, PA minimum coverage, full vs limited tort, and home-auto bundle options.
Find the best insurance agent in the Lehigh Valley. Compare independent agents who shop multiple carriers versus captive State Farm and Allstate agents. Learn how to choose the right agent for auto, home, and business insurance in Allentown, Bethlehem, and Easton.