Paranormal Pizza

“I LOVE PARANORMAL PIZZA Co.! The food is consistently amazing as well as creative (new menu items and versions are added, tested and offered frequently). Personally I am not a huge pizza person, but my husband is and while he is not vegan he LOVES Paranormal’s pizza and says it stands up to any ‘regular’ pizza he has ever had. He loves the sourdough dough that they use! Now I must rave about the SEITAN WINGS! I am a seitan girl, and paranormal makes their own, and it is next level! Their wings are hands down my all time favorite! I live approx an hour and a half away and I make a point to get there a couple times a month just for the wings! (& of course I always bring extra home to air -fry up at home in between visits😋) Their are 3 main sauce options for the wings (bbq, buffalo and garlic parm), however every week there is also a ‘weekly special sauce’- which I get so excited for! They announce the special on their social media each week. Another item I must highly recommend is the “Pulled Porkless Sandwich”… it comes topped with coleslaw and pickles and is down right amazing! The owners are also such hard- working, friendly and kind people that you can’t help but look forward to seeing when you come in. If you’ve never visited, this is your sign to do so! See below some of the pics of items my husband and I have ordered over the course of our many visits🫶🏻”

“Delicious vegan pizza. I was sceptical about the pepperoni but it was really good. The crust is perfect. A member of my group also got the gluten free crust and it was super good and deep dish and the bread was awesome even tho it was gluten free. Garlic nots were also very delicious. 10/10 Staff very informative about what was in the pizzas and ingredients in the gluten free crust.”

“Drove down from central NJ as we had this place bookmarked for over a year. Our son had the special- Bacn Mac n cheese burger and we also got one order of buffalo wings and one garlic parm wings - both extra crispy. The mac n cheese in the burger was pure salt and overpowering- we think perhaps someone accidentally double salted it during prep. It had potential but we also thought it would be a veggie burger with bacn rather than just the bacon and mac. The buffalo wings were nice and crisp. Wish it came with some blue cheese or ranch and celery for dipping and contrast. The garlic parm wings were drenched in butter and there was plenty of garlic to be tasted but hardly any parm. Another rookie mistake by myself expecting these to be a dry rub style wing. We didnt try the pizza but offerings were creative and I imagine it is decent. Staff was friendly and food comes out fast.”

“Fantastic atmosphere with some of the best vegan pizza around! Traveled about an hour to get here and it was 100% worth it. Also, you need to add the garlic knots to your pizza crust! Can’t wait to come back and try their mozzarella sticks!”

“owner was very nice & knowledgeable. himself and staff were very hospitable to everyone who entered the restaurant the pizza had an amazing crunch & taste. & the Cheesesteak was AMAZING SOFT SOFT ROOL & GOOD FLAVOR. I WAS FULL FROM ONE SLICE & HALF OF THE CHEESESTEAK. BUT NOT BLOATED FUL. HIGHLY RECOMMEND”