Italian Restaurants in Bethlehem, PA: 3 Spots Compared
Quick Answer: Bethlehem has three Italian-tagged restaurants in our directory data: Apollo Grill on West Broad Street, Tre Scalini Ristorante on East Broad Street, and Bruno Scipioni's Italian Ristorante & Pizzeria on Easton Avenue. Apollo Grill holds the highest rating at 4.7 and by far the deepest review record, and Bruno Scipioni's is the only one open every day of the week.
Key Takeaways:
- Highest rating: Apollo Grill, at 4.7 in our directory data.
- Deepest review record: Apollo Grill at 1,900 reviews — more than the other two combined.
- Only one open every day: Bruno Scipioni's Italian Ristorante & Pizzeria, per our directory data.
- One isn't quite what it sounds like: Apollo Grill is tagged in our Italian listings, but Google's own data classifies it as a Bar & Grill, and its description doesn't mention Italian cuisine at all.
- Shortcut: Browse all Italian restaurants in the Lehigh Valley, or see our Allentown Italian guide and the valley-wide Italian roundup.
What Are the Italian Options in Bethlehem?
Italian Restaurants Bethlehem PA: Our directory already has an Allentown-specific Italian guide and a valley-wide roundup, but Bethlehem's own three Italian-tagged listings have never had a page of their own. Two of the three sit on Broad Street itself — Apollo Grill on the west end, Tre Scalini on the east end — while the third, Bruno Scipioni's, is on Easton Avenue.
Local rule of thumb: Check what you're actually getting before you book. Apollo Grill is listed under our Italian subcategory, but Google's own data classifies it as a Bar & Grill, and its own directory description calls out American entrees and a full bar rather than Italian cooking. If you specifically want Italian food, Tre Scalini and Bruno Scipioni's are the two that Google itself classifies as Italian restaurants.
Which Spot Has the Highest Rating?
Apollo Grill holds the top rating at 4.7 stars in our directory data. Tre Scalini Ristorante and Bruno Scipioni's are tied just behind at 4.6 — all three sit within a tenth of a point of each other.
Which Spot Has the Deepest Review Record?
Apollo Grill stands well above the other two at 1,900 reviews in our directory data — more than double Bruno Scipioni's 763. Bruno Scipioni's is second at 763, and Tre Scalini has the thinnest record of the three at 330, despite matching Apollo Grill on rating.
How Do the Hours Really Compare?
Bruno Scipioni's is the only one of the three open every single day in our directory data, running 11am-8pm Monday through Thursday and Sunday, with later 11am-10pm hours Friday and Saturday. Apollo Grill is closed Mondays and Sundays, open Tuesday through Saturday 11am-10pm. Tre Scalini is also closed Mondays and Sundays, and is dinner-only on top of that, running 5-10pm Tuesday through Saturday with no lunch service at all.
What About Alcohol and Reservations?
Apollo Grill and Bruno Scipioni's both list a full bar — beer, wine, and cocktails — in our directory data. Tre Scalini lists wine only, consistent with its description as a BYOB restaurant. All three accept reservations.
Which Spot Serves Lunch?
Apollo Grill and Bruno Scipioni's both serve lunch alongside dinner in our directory data. Tre Scalini is dinner-only, with no lunch or breakfast service listed at all.
What About Delivery, Takeout, and Kids?
Bruno Scipioni's is the only one of the three that lists delivery in our directory data, alongside dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup. Apollo Grill offers dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup, but no delivery. Tre Scalini is dine-in and takeout only, with neither delivery nor curbside pickup. Bruno Scipioni's is also the only one of the three with a children's menu, on top of being good for kids.
What About Price and Parking?
Apollo Grill carries the highest price tier of the three at three dollar signs in our directory data. Bruno Scipioni's sits at two dollar signs; Tre Scalini has no price tier listed. Parking tells a similar story: Apollo Grill's options are entirely paid — a paid lot, paid street, and paid garage. Tre Scalini offers a mix of free and paid lot parking plus free street parking. Bruno Scipioni's is the most generous of the three, with free lot and free street parking only — no paid option needed.
What About Accessibility?
All three report the full set of wheelchair-accessible entrance, parking, restroom, and seating in Google's verified data — the one area where there's no differentiation at all among the three. That's worth knowing on its own, since accessibility gaps have turned up as a real, meaningful differentiator in several of our other city-by-city restaurant comparisons.
Is This Good for a Group Dinner?
All three list themselves as good for groups in our directory data, so that isn't a deciding factor either. Apollo Grill and Tre Scalini both list coffee and dessert on top of that, rounding out a full dinner experience without needing a second stop. Bruno Scipioni's also lists coffee and dessert, plus outdoor seating, which neither of the other two highlights as prominently in combination with its other family-oriented features.
How Does Bethlehem Compare to the Rest of the Valley?
Bethlehem's three Italian-tagged listings are the largest single-city cluster in our directory data. Allentown and Hellertown each have just one, and Easton has two — seven Italian-tagged restaurants total across the entire Lehigh Valley, more than half of them concentrated right here in Bethlehem. If you're comparing beyond Bethlehem, see our Allentown Italian guide for that single listing, or the valley-wide roundup for all seven side by side.
What About Payment Methods?
Apollo Grill and Bruno Scipioni's both accept credit cards, debit cards, and contactless payments in our directory data. Tre Scalini accepts credit and debit cards but doesn't list contactless payments — worth knowing if that's how you typically pay, though a missing field in Google's data may simply mean it hasn't been reported rather than that the restaurant genuinely doesn't take tap-to-pay cards.
Is Apollo Grill Really an Italian Restaurant?
Worth sitting with for a moment, since it's the single biggest surprise in this comparison. Our directory tags Apollo Grill under the Italian subcategory, but Google's own primary-type field for the listing is "Bar & Grill," and the description on file describes an extensive appetizer menu, American entrees, and a full bar — nothing at all about pasta, Sicilian cooking, or any other specifically Italian dish the way Tre Scalini and Bruno Scipioni's both are. That doesn't make Apollo Grill a bad choice at all — it has, by a wide margin, the deepest review record of all three listings — but if you're specifically craving Italian food rather than a downtown bar-and-grill night out, the other two are by far the more literal, accurate match for that craving.
Which Spot Fits Which Trip?
- Want the deepest track record? Apollo Grill, at 1,900 reviews.
- Need a Sunday or Monday dinner? Bruno Scipioni's is the only one open either day.
- Bringing the kids? Bruno Scipioni's is the only one with a children's menu and delivery.
- Want a BYOB night out? Tre Scalini is the one built for it.
- Parking without paying? Bruno Scipioni's is the only one with entirely free parking options.
- Paying by tap or phone? Apollo Grill and Bruno Scipioni's both take contactless; Tre Scalini doesn't list it.
- Want the lighter-touch BYOB option? Tre Scalini is the one with a wine-only, bring-your-own setup.
Bottom Line: Two Italian Kitchens and a Bar That Shares the Tag
Bethlehem's three Italian-tagged restaurants aren't quite three of a kind. Tre Scalini and Bruno Scipioni's are both Italian restaurants by Google's own classification, with Bruno Scipioni's winning on availability — open every day, with delivery and a children's menu — and Tre Scalini offering the quieter, BYOB, dinner-only experience. Apollo Grill carries the deepest review record of the three by far, but it's worth knowing going in that Google itself files it as a Bar & Grill, not an Italian restaurant — a useful reminder that a directory's own category tags are a starting point for browsing, not a guarantee of what's actually on the menu. For the wider picture, see our Allentown Italian guide and the valley-wide Italian roundup.
Find the best local businesses in Lehigh Valley. Browse our curated directory of Italian restaurants and all Bethlehem restaurants — real businesses vetted by locals, not paid placements.
