Bethlehem Dairy Store
4.7✓ Verified August 2026(1,963 Google reviews)
About Bethlehem Dairy Store
Bethlehem ice cream landmark on Linden Street, scooping homemade ice cream since the 1930s. Locals know it as 'The Cup,' after the giant milkshake-cup shape of the original stand.
Why We Recommend Them
Generations of Bethlehem kids grew up on The Cup, and the homemade flavors still hold up. Some places are institutions because they earned it — this is one of them.
Price Range
$
Google Rating
4.7 / 5
Reviews
1,963
City
Bethlehem
